Victoria Woodhull 1838-1927
With the UK election of 2010 officially announced this week, the VV has been musing on political matters and, in particular, on the life of Victoria Woodhull – the very first woman to stand for the American presidency as far back as 1872. Not that her attempt met with any success. At that time women had no legal vote and, on the day of Grant’s re-election his female rival was safely imprisoned on charges of libel and pornography. But, what had preceded such ignominy?
Buck Claflin in old age
Born in Ohio, into a large family of shameless rogues, much of Victoria's early life had been spent as part of her father’s travelling medicine show. Always having a talent to draw a crowd, the little girl would preach and tell fortunes, even claiming the power to cure all ills while her father – the one-eyed Reuben ‘Buck’ Claflin – stood at the back of his wagon and sold bottles of his opium-based Life Elixir.
At the age of fourteen Victoria fell ill, driven to the point of exhaustion after being deliberately starved by Buck as a means of enhancing her spiritual ‘visions’. Victoria later claimed that her father sexually abused her when drunk, even trying to sell her as a whore. But then, she would be seduced soon enough when, during her convalescence, she was wooed by another fraud - the apparently well-to-do doctor who was known as Canning Woodhull.
Canning, who was then twenty-eight, asked for Victoria’s hand and offered the girl a means of escape from her father’s tyrannical, grasping ways. But, once again she was misused. Her ‘Doc’ was no more than a worthless quack, an opium addict and womaniser. Unable to support his child bride, he was so drunk at the birth of their son that Victoria very nearly died, and blamed her husband evermore for the boy’s severe mental impairments.
When contemplating returning to Buck, Victoria came to realise that her place in the family ‘enterprise’ had been usurped by her younger sister, Tennessee. So, with husband and idiot son in tow she made her way to San Francisco, there hoping to realise a dream. As a small child, Victoria claimed to have had a vision in which the spirit of the Greek orator, Demosthenes, foretold of a glorious destiny in which she would grow up to lead the American people – a position that she would hold in a city of water and ships and gold. Well, San Francisco seemed to fit the bill, being the scene of the gold rush and also a sea port town. But any dreams of success were soon crushed. While Canning spent every cent he owned in opium dens and on prostitutes Victoria was left with no choice but to support her family, working as a cigar girl in a bar, as an actress, and probably a whore.
Returning at last to Ohio, rather than joining Buck’s latest venture (running a dubious hospital from which he advertised himself as ‘America’s King of Cancers), along with her sister, Tennessee, Victoria worked as a spiritual healer – though many have come to suspect that the sisters offered a somewhat more physical sustenance.
Colonel James Harvey Blood
While in such trade, Victoria met the married Colonel, James Harvey Blood. Blood was a glamorous civil war hero who shared her belief in ‘other realms’ and fervently supported her ‘destiny’ as future ruler of America. Leaving his respectable life behind, as well as his wife and daughters, he joined Victoria and Tennessee when they set out to make their mark in New York – another city of gold and ships.
At first, times were hard and the sisters' spiritualist business was bolstered by the sale of contraceptive devices to the prostitutes they befriended. Meanwhile, Blood was often absent, spending time with his brother’s newspaper business and learning the tricks of that trade – publishing pamphlets and magazines deemed to be a vital means of spreading the word of Victoria’s aims when she set her cap at the presidency.
Cornelius Vandervilt
Before that, the bad penny Buck Claflin turned up. Having heard that the aging, widowed businessman, Cornelius Vanderbilt – then the richest man in America – was seeking the services of mediums, he contrived a means of introducing his daughters. Matters rapidly progressed. Victoria became Vanderbilt’s personal medium with ’the ‘spirits’ offering financial tips which, in reality, were gleaned from gossiping bankers in brothels. Tennessee became Vanderbilt’s mistress – a natural progression of events after performing her ‘magnetic healing’ and curing the 'old goat's' niggling complaints.
A contemporary newspaper cartoon of Victoria and Tennie as Wall Street traders
Generously rewarded, the sisters caused a public sensation by setting themselves up as Wall Street’s very first female brokers - an enterprise that brought further wealth. With the aid of Colonel Blood, they then founded a spiritualist newspaper and Woodhull & Claflin’s Weekly became their political voice – a voice that reached a great many ears, for the religion of Spiritualism was at that time widely followed, offering a rare platform from which women could express their views.
Victoria Woodhull addressing the House Judiciary Committee
Holding spectacular salons, Victoria was soon courted by the Women’s Movement who supported her bid for the presidency. She lectured to enormous crowds and under the popular banner of universal suffrage and equal rights, Victoria travelled to Washington to petition the House at a Judiciary Committee in 1871.
But, things soon began to deteriorate. With Buck’s criminal antics raked up in the press alongside stories of her dubious past, ‘The Woodhull’ was being demonised as no less than ‘Mrs Satan’. A crippling series of court cases followed which led to her being sued and imprisoned time and time again. Her outspoken thoughts regarding 'free love' caused even more offence when combined with an ill-advised liaison with the press man, Theodore Tilton.
Theodore Tilton
It was a complicated affair. Tilton's wife had been sexually involved with a popular married clergyman whose name was Henry Ward Beecher. Beecher in return had sworn to offer Victoria's campaign support before having second thoughts. Victoria then sought revenge by exposing Beecher's adultery, only to find herself immersed in the ‘Trial of the Century’. Beecher was to come out unscathed. The Tiltons were socially disgraced, and Victoria had been portrayed as a promiscuous pornographer. Her life and ambitions were ruined – politically, personally and financially.
It was Vanderbilt who brought some salvation. When the old man died his heirs were keen to hush up the millionaire's less than salubrious past. Victoria and Tennessee were given a generous settlement and with this they travelled to England, settling in London; another city of gold and ships in which they reinvented themselves, leaving their lovers and scandal behind - along with all dreams of the presidency. Nevertheless, they attained some degree of success. Tennessee married a viscount and became known as Lady Cook.
Victoria and John Biddulph Martin - happy and 'respectable' at last
Victoria married John Biddulph Martin, a bachelor merchant banker. When widowed she was heartbroken - but rich. Withdrawing to the Martin's country estate, she became a passionate motorist, founding an agricultural college for women, a village school, and a country club – at which Edward, the Prince of Wales was said to be a frequent visitor.
The VV wonders how Victoria felt when, at the age of eighty, universal suffrage was finally won – when the 'modern' world had all but forgotten the woman who once caused a national sensation and was known as the wife of the devil. All but in exile at the time of her death she asked for no more than to be remembered with the following brief words:
‘You cannot understand a man’s work by what he has accomplished, but by what he has overcome in accomplishing it.’
In her own way, and by her own means, Victoria Woodhull achieved a great deal. She was one of the many brave Victorians who lived in a time when a woman was seen as no more than a man's possession. She paved the way for equality – though who knows when her ultimate hope will come true, when a woman will stand in the White House as president of America.
The VV has hardly scratched the surface of Victoria Woodhull's amazing life. Should any readers wish to investigate further there is a wealth of information on the web. As far as books are concerned, Other Powers by Barabara Goldsmith is an excellent resource which gives a full and well-researched view of relevant historical events at the time. Mary Gabriel's Notorious Victoria is another fine investigation. And, for younger historians, Kathleen Krull's A Woman for President is a good starting point which has the added bonus of being brought to vibrant life by Jane Dyer's watercolour illustrations.
The VV has hardly scratched the surface of Victoria Woodhull's amazing life. Should any readers wish to investigate further there is a wealth of information on the web. As far as books are concerned, Other Powers by Barabara Goldsmith is an excellent resource which gives a full and well-researched view of relevant historical events at the time. Mary Gabriel's Notorious Victoria is another fine investigation. And, for younger historians, Kathleen Krull's A Woman for President is a good starting point which has the added bonus of being brought to vibrant life by Jane Dyer's watercolour illustrations.












This was fascinating. I never knew anything about this woman. Your posts are always interesting and informative.
ReplyDeleteThanks again, Ann...I only found her while researching 'New York spiritualists'. It's such an amazing story. She was incredibly famous in her time and her history was then almost entirely covered up...probably because of her lack of 'respectability'.
ReplyDeleteBloody brilliant story!
ReplyDeleteI would ignore the problem of historians writing her out of history because of her lack of respectability. That happened to women all the time, and it is up to later women historians to reclaim the real stories.
But as you presented Victoria Woodhull, she was a very ambiguous character. On one hand she was left with no choice but to support her family in a range of tough jobs. She learned the tricks of the newspaper business, publishing pamphlets and magazines. And best of all Victoria lectured to enormous crowds re universal suffrage and equal rights.
But on the other hand there was a long family history of nastiness. Male dominated, to be sure, but I wonder if Victoria could have distanced herself publicly from the criminal behaviour.
I agree with you that the religion of Spiritualism was at that time widely followed but do you think Victoria was a true believer? Or just using Spiritualism to con people for her own ends?
I echo Ann. What a great story!
ReplyDeleteWhat NY spiritualist research are you doing? Another fascinating subject. If I ever have a free minute, I'd love to go upstate and visit their old haunts. New York in the 19th century was a hotbed of activity -- Utopian communities, spiritualism, and the birth of Mormonism.
Well done Sarah - I've always had an interest in Victoria Woodhull since discovering her about ten years ago. A fascinating woman. Have you read Barbara Goldsmith's 'Other Powers' about Victoria and her sister. What a gloriously scandalous pair. That's hwy I love the Victorians!
ReplyDeleteHels - I do think Victoria was a complex and ambiguous character - trying to write a clear, short sketch of her here was very hard! She undoubtedly suffered a great deal, but was strong, determined and skilful enough to fight her way out poverty by whatever means at her disposal. She offered several contradictory stories about her own past and despite fighting for the rights of women, my next post will show how, on a personal level, her actions could also be selfish and lead to tragic consequences.
ReplyDeleteShe clearly had a problem with distancing herself from her family - whether to keep them quiet, or because of a sense of duty. But, then again, she was loyal to Canning Woodhull and when he turned up on her doorstep, dying from alcoholic poisoning, she welcomed him in to live in her home despite the fact that such a peculiar arrangement - living with her first husband and Colonel Blood (who she claimed to have also married, though that is another grey area conveniently forgotten when she travelled to London).
Her parents brought great shame and disgrace. They were like leeches, even following their daughters to London. Buck's criminal past was like a curse but, without him, would the 'girls' have met Mr Vanderbilt or gained the wealth and influence to make their own mark on the New York stage? So, all very complex and, as you say, at times very nasty.
Victoria's views on spiritualism were, in my mind, simply another means to an end. She clearly had great charisma and sexual allure. Many eminent men and women were held in her spell and bent over backwards to support her political aspirations. She also told a good story and the visions she claims to have seen (including one of her conception!) are almost comical though all are perfectly suited to the design of her 'great destiny'.
Oops - forget to add the end of sentence back there. I had intended to say that when Victoria lived in a menage a trois with Canning Woodhall and Colonel Blood, the scandal was reported in all of the press after being dragged to their attention by Victoria's own mother, Roxy. Roxy had always resented Victoria for taking Tennessee away and Roxy was determined to reek revenge when Victoria threw her out of the house for encouraging Canning's habit yet more and supplying him with opium.
ReplyDeleteLiam - you're so right. It is the most fascinating era. I was doing some very general research on spiritualism and the woman's movement. I'd never heard of Victoria Woodhull, but her name kept coming up again and again and how could I ignore her?
ReplyDeleteHelen - I love everything about Victoria's story - so brave and daring and scheming with every element you could ever want in a sensational novel. Such an ADVENTURE!
I did try to write a novel about her, but when trying to cram every element in, I think I lost the 'plot'. But, one day, I will come back to her...I think I may have been possessed!
Victoria Woodhull is one of my favorite women. I wrote about her when the presidential election rolled around. I'm amazed that no one has done a HBO miniseries about her. So far there's just been a Broadway musical. Barbara Goldsmith's biography is excellent as is Marion Meade's.
ReplyDeleteElizabeth - a tv series of film would be wonderful. Victoria's life has drama in spades... and then some!
ReplyDeleteI always liked the (Mrs) Satan cartoon-- today it looks like Woodhull is offering free love and goth cosplay!
ReplyDeleteNo contest, says I!
Yamara - I love it!
ReplyDeleteDear Virtual. I may call you Virtual, mayn't I? Anyway very interesting and fun stuff. I can't remember the road here cuuz I was doing hideous tax form. I am an old fossil and I am going to send a link to you to all my friends. I was going to say "girlfriends" but I didn't wan't to sound like a masher. That cartoon of her with the "devil wings" is really attractive. I wish I had a set of those suckers. Hilary Clinton springs to mind somehow. OK . I like your stuff. I will send you a number of customers! I'll be back. I have to try to write a coherent sentence myself. Best wishes. This chick is sort of like the Alanis of yesteryear.
ReplyDeleteIt's easy to tell you read Goldsmith's "Other Powers." She's the first author to suggest Victoria was sexually abused. IMHO, if you're the first to make an explosive claim, you need to provide solid evidence. Goldsmith doesn't. She says the words in Theodore Tilton's bio, "a woman before her time," indicate sexual abuse. I've read the bio, and my impression is that household drudgery and raising younger siblings matured her. She took on the housework of a woman while a child. Until Goldsmith provides proof of her allegation, it should be dismissed as pure speculation. Victoria NEVER claimed she was sexually abused.
ReplyDeleteI spoke with Barbara Goldsmith. She seems to be a sweet lady with a passion for research, but I don't like her book, because it's improperly sourced and doesn't clearly distinguish between facts and rumors. She presents as fact that Victoria was a prostitute, while using unsubstantiated rumors as proof of the "fact." Goldsmith writes, "He [Buck] advertised in the Ottawa Free Trader that on the first floor of the Fox River House lessons in the 'cult of love' were to be taught." The footnotes say the source is the Ottawa Free Trader, April 4, 1863. There is no "Cult of Love" ad in that issue! I've read a year's worth of issues and have yet to find a "Cult of Love" ad.
I challenge anyone to provide proof that Victoria was a prostitute. According to the Chicago Mail in the 1890's, she was arrested for it in the 1860's, and it was in all the newspapers. Funny thing is no one has found any of those articles. They seem to be non-existent like the "Cult of Love" ad.
Col. Blood was the step-father of my great-grandfather, so I know a great deal about him. Colonel married my great-great-grandmother Isabell. She was his third wife. He had only one daughter from his first wife. As for his marriage to Victoria, I obtained copies of the marriage records for both of the times he married Victoria. Now, you could argue the legality of those marriages, but Ohio had common law marriage at that time. They were, at the least, common law spouses until their divorce in 1876.
What was the name of George Blood's newspaper you mentioned? George lived with my family, and to my knowledge he never had his own newspaper. George worked for Woodhull & Claflin's Weekly where Colonel was Managing Editor.
What's your source for the elixir having opium in it? It was purely vegetable based. And what's your evidence that they sold contraceptive devices? That, too, is speculation. Elizabeth Lemons in her Harvard doctoral dissertation says Victoria's "consistent denunciations of contraceptive devices and abortion elsewhere suggest that she was not promoting them."
There are many inaccuracies about Victoria Woodhull that have been perpetuated by relying on secondary, rather than primary sources. In 1928, Emanie Sachs wrote that my great-great-grandmother "Mrs. Fogg" was a wealthy, elderly widow. She was wrong on all three counts; and yet, Johanna Johnston, M.M. Marberry, and Irving Wallace all repeated the error. Barbara Goldsmith gave the name of my great-great-grandmother as the name of Col. Blood's first wife, rather than his third wife. Goldsmith's book provides a colorful backdrop of the gilded age, but it perpetuates decades old myths and creates new ones.
Dear M Shearer,
ReplyDeleteFirst of all I'm so sorry if anything I've written here has caused you offence. I have not gone to primary sources, that is true, and as the title of my blog hints, most of my research is online and 'virtual' though via what I hope are 'good' sources.
I did order actual books from America, and amongst them were the Goldsmith book which was very well reviewed in all the good press here. I also read Notorious Victoria by Gabriel, Harriet and Isabella - a novel by O'Brien, and some of Victoria Woodhull's own speeches and tracts including Free Lover and Lady Eugenist.
I can imagine, from what you've now said, that perhaps - as so often happens today - her name was demonised and dragged through the mud in an attempt to get rid of her threat politically. That happened, I'm sure - but without reading the material again right now, including her own works, I did get the distinct impression that many of those rumours were true.
You've inspired me to go back and look again, one day when I have the time. Victoria Woodhull was fasinating - and fascinating people to tend to cause jealousy and slander which it's hard to unravel as time goes by.
By the way, I wonder if you know how Colonel Blood died. I read that he went to Africa, looking for gold. Was this true or just another fabrication?
Thank you for an excellent comment which I hope others will find here. I'm sure those who read the post will do. And, once again, I regret causing any offence.
Essie
Thank you for the apology; it's not necessary. I simply want to set the record straight. Tilton's bio claimed that Victoria's father beat her but didn't claim sexual abuse. Her sisters denied Buck beat her. Tilton was opposed to corporal punishment so that may have colored his account of Victoria's childhood. We'll probably never know which Claflin was telling the truth, but Victoria cared for her father in his old age, and he looked up to her. If any abuse occurred, she forgave him for it.
ReplyDeleteGoldsmith's book did get good reviews which could lead someone to think it's an authoritative source on everything Woodhull. It's more of a social history of her era, rather than a biography of her. Some reviews praised Goldsmith's extensive footnotes, but I've had a few authors complain to me about them. She cited non-existent issues of newspapers, or the source she cited wasn't the right one. Her footnotes look impressive until you actually try to use them. If she has proof of her allegations, it's buried in her private research boxes. That doesn't make for good history.
Personally, I prefer the books by Mary Gabriel and Amanda Frisken. Mary Gabriel understands Victoria Woodhull in a way that Goldsmith doesn't, while Frisken has done original research with primary sources. "Free Lover" and "Lady Eugenist," like "The Victoria Woodhull Reader," are good for reproductions of Victoria's lectures, but I'd skip Michael W. Perry's commentary. He has an agenda that is rabidly pro-life and anti-liberal.
If someone can prove that Victoria Woodhull was a prostitute, I'll change my opinion. For every person that says she was, I can find someone who says she was falsely maligned for being a pioneer in women's rights. It's a little known fact that she sued a publisher for libel in 1876 for alleging she was a prostitute. Unfortunately, the publisher died before he had to testify in court, so we'll never know how the lawsuit would've turned out. I also discovered that both my family and Victoria Woodhull's family threatened to sue Emanie Sachs for libel for her 1928 biography. I think my family must've scared Sachs, because she left out certain things, probably because her publisher's attorneys said she could get arrested for criminal libel.
Keep in mind that Victoria was often confused with her sister Tennessee. Tennessee would say or do things that would get attributed to Victoria. They had very different personalities. Tennessee was lively, flirtatious, and entertained people by saying outrageous things. Victoria was more reserved and dignified. There's a possibility Tennessee could've been forced into prostitution, but Victoria considered herself sovereign over her own body and swore she'd never give her body up for money. For love, yes, but not money.
Col. Blood did go to Africa looking for gold. He died on his 52nd birthday in the Gold Coast of Africa (present day Ghana) in Akanten in the region of Axim and was buried on the road to Winnebah. My great-grandfather brought his body back from Africa to bury it in Brooklyn, NY. I have the map of the Gold Coast that he took with him. There were rumors that Colonel was murdered, but that's doubtful. I haven't found a death certificate for him yet, but the family said he died of "jungle fever" AKA malaria. My great-grandfather came down with it, too. Colonel was said to have a heart condition that his brother George thought killed him. The books that say Colonel went to South Africa are wrong, and it's pure fabrication that he went there to win Victoria back. He went there to make a living. He did strike gold. My grandpa used to have a vial of gold dust that Col. Blood mined, but the last time my mother saw it was in the 1950's.
Victoria and Theodore bathed together in the nude? LOL. The claim that they "bathed" together at Coney Island came from the testimony of John Gallagher, a coachman, in the Beecher-Tilton trial. His testimony starts on page 377 of Vol. II of McDivitt's trial transcript. His testimony doesn't say they swam nude. According to the New York Daily Graphic, Mar. 24, 1875, Gallagher's testimony "disappointed the lawyers. This was the coachman who drove Mr. Tilton and Mrs. Woodhull to Coney Island. He led the counsel to believe that he knew of these persons bathing togethes[sic]--saw their hair dripping with brine and heard them comment on their bath. On the stand his memory proved defective, and he could not be brought to narrate one-half as much as he did to the counsel." Gallagher testified that he held onto their watches while they went out to swim near Green's Hotel, but he didn't see them in the water. Don't you think nude bathers in the summer at a populous Coney Island resort would've drawn a great deal of attention? If they went bathing together at Coney Island, and Tilton denied that they did, they most likely would've been clothed.
ReplyDelete